Hamburger Menu Alternatives for Mobile Navigation

Posted 2 years ago by Zoltan Kollin

If you’re working on digital products, you have already read dozens of articles describing how and why the hamburger navigation on mobile (and desktop!) hurts UX metrics due of its low discoverability and efficiency. (You can read some of best articles on the topic here, here, here, and here.)

Luckily, more and more sites and apps are experimenting with alternative, more efficient solutions for this very problem. None of the ideas listed here is better than the others, their viability and performance obviously depend on the content and the context.

“Viability and performance depend on the content and the context.”

1. Tabs

If you have a limited number of sections in your website or app and users should be able to quickly switch between these sections, a tabbed navigation might be the solution.

Tabs seem to be the simplest navigation pattern, however, you need to consider a few things when designing them:

Examples: LinkedIn and Google Photos

Icon-only tabs on LinkedIn and icon+label tabs on Google Photos

Icon-only tabs on LinkedIn and icon+label tabs on Google Photos

2. Tabs with a ‘more’ option

When there are more than 5 main sections, a practical solution might be to show the four most prioritized sections and have a fifth element list ‘everything else’:


14j5uSBlUujdP39uQioxbeA

The design principles for this solution are basically the same as for simple tabs. The ‘more’ item can either link to a navigation page or work as a dropdown menu with the remaining sections:

1Bwd-AhGD13PJo20VD_SAVQ

You could argue that the ‘more’ item isn’t better than the hamburger menu (it’s kind of hidden and its label does not refer to its content at all), however, if you have made the prioritization right, most users will be looking for one of the four visible items anyway so the navigation experience for the majority will still be improved.

Example: Facebook

News feed, friend requests, notification, and search is always available in the header, all the remaining functionality is available from the ‘more’ menu on Facebook

News feed, friend requests, notification, and search is always available in the header, all the remaining functionality is available from the ‘more’ menu on Facebook

3. Progressively collapsing menu

A more sophisticated version of the ‘tabs + more’ navigation is to design a menu that adapts to the screen width, shows as much of the navigation as possible, and puts everything else under a More item if necessary:

1jT8yOdJXH7lN5JxfqYYfEA

This means that the More menu contains more items on a lower resolution?—?items ‘jump’ under More when there’s not enough space to show them. The flexibility of this solution provides a better experience than the ‘tabs + more’, especially on in-between screen sizes.

Example: BBC

1sV5B5VzQWrnpcf82khU9IQ

The main menu of BBC is rendered according to the actual screen size to always show as many items as possible

4. Scrollable navigation

If you have a number of navigation items without a big distinction in priorities and having a ‘more’ category would be a bad compromise, another strategy is to list all the items in a scrollable view:

1fdte_FzZ0uh-f-3t5GrwwQ

The downside of this solution is that still only the top few items are visible without scrolling and all the remaining ones are off the canvas. This is, however, an acceptable solution when the users are expected to explore the content, e.g. in a web shop or news categories.

As far as visual design is concerned you need to make sure to provide enough visual hints to suggest that there are more elements available upon horizontal scrolling (e.g. by fading and/or off positioning the last visible element).

Examples: Medium and Google

The main categories can be scrolled at smaller screen sizes on Medium.com

The main categories can be scrolled at smaller screen sizes on Medium.com

Categories of the Google search results page are available in a scrollable view

Categories of the Google search results page are available in a scrollable view

5. Dropdown menus

An uncommon but interesting pattern is to use dropdown-like menus when the visibility and accessibility of the other sections is not essential:

1nKlPdP8w6xPmdQCsguwfJg

The dropdown menu actually has a double role in this case: first, it serves as a page title and the downward arrow suggests that there’s a possibility to quickly switch to similar sections. Although the options are hidden in this case, the dropdown design suggests that the list would contain options that are either siblings or children of the current page (and it should primarily be used for this purpose).

Example: Barnes & Noble and Duolingo

When browsing books, the current category and the navigation/filtering options are always available in a dropdown menu on bn.com

When browsing books, the current category and the navigation/filtering options are always available in a dropdown menu on bn.com

While not a common interaction for most users, Duolingo allows to quickly switch between the languages you practice via a dropdown

While not a common interaction for most users, Duolingo allows to quickly switch between the languages you practice via a dropdown

And sometimes, surprisingly, the hamburger menu might be a good choice

Since the main downside of the hamburger menu is its low discoverability, it’s recommended to consider one of the alternatives when it comes to designing the main navigation menu. However, when designing secondary navigation options, this pattern might be an appropriate solution.

If the primary options are available as prominent on-screen call to action buttons, the hamburger menu seems a good place for all the secondary navigation:

1PYJ_Hvs7ng9abfl-dLKDpQ

This pattern can be used when the main navigation is designed around a user flow and the related options are clearly available on the screen. Uber might be a good example:

1hPnxkp_z9oEzgl-6mbSuZA

Since everything about this screen is designed to request a car, secondary options such as History and Settings should not be available more prominently than from a hamburger menu.

Google Translate is really similar to this:

1BpNyxtQQpD2Hwj8xBU8bTw

Since the main functionality (switching languages and entering text to translate) is the most prominent part of the screen, the hidden menu is a great place to host sections like Help and Community.

Conclusion

“There isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution for mobile navigation”

There isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution for mobile navigation, it always depends on your product, on your users, and on the context. What works well for others might not work for you and vice versa. However, the foundation of every well designed navigation is information architecture – clear structure, priorities, and labels based on your users’ needs. So why not start finding the most efficient mobile navigation for your product today?

This article was originally published on Zoltan’s Medium page.

Prototype with Sketch!

Prototype with Sketch!

Send artboards straight from Sketch into your Marvel projects.

Download Plugin

UX enthusiast and design manager at IBM Budapest Lab (former Ustream). Speaker. Organizer of Amuse conference. Find me on Twitter or Medium.

Related Posts

We increasingly rely on digital systems to either mediate or replace human communications. But often, these experiences feel clunky and impersonal, or even scammy and deceptive. Asking Alexa to add something to my shopping cart is a breeze: “Hey Alexa, add bananas to my shopping list.” “Okay, I’ve added bananas to your shopping list.” But if I want to add… Read More →

I’ve had several recruiters read my resumé about my experience in Design Systems and contact me about jobs. Only to find out they were hiring for people with Systems Design experience. I’ll be outlining what both topics are and help people understand the qualities of each. Design Systems An engineer who works on a design system typically has some interest… Read More →

I love stories. One of my favorites is the legend of how James Cameron pitched his idea for Aliens, the sequel to Ridley Scott’s 1979 film Alien—an example I always hoped was true until Lynda Obst confirmed its authenticity in her book Hello, He Lied. Even though it grossed over $100 million at the box office—on a measly $11 million… Read More →