How to Mash-Up and Benefit from PM and the Design Thinking Process

Posted 3 weeks ago by Dan Nessler

The Homer a mash-up car made for one user – Homer

Ever struggled with managing your projects or PMs trying to do so? Well, there is an app… hmm… or something different for that.

Recently I took on the Design Council’s Double Diamond process, “revamped” it, and published it (Link at the end of the post). People have questioned how my approach would relate to “real” project management and projects.

This follow-up post is about my mash-up approach to answering this. This is not about comparing the HCD process to PM but to overlay the two disciplines in order to gain an understanding when working in an environment where people rely one or the other.

“Mashing-up stuff doesn’t always work…but I’m doin it anyway.”

If you are familiar with my Revamped Double Diamond Design process skip the next paragraph.

Revamped Double Diamond

The Revamped Double Diamond is a design process framework based on the Design Council’s (2007) Double Diamond.

Latest and slightly updated version of my Revamped Double Diamond (01.09.2016). “Themas and clusters” are now a before “Insights”

It aims at making sense of the design process and providing guidance and clarity in order to tackle a design challenge. The framework incorporates tools, methods and techniques from various sources to do so (find links to my detailed article at the end of this post).

Project Management in a nutshell

“Project management is the application of knowledge, skills, tools, and techniques to project activities to meet the project requirements” (PMI, 2013).

I’m not going deeper into PM theory and focus on two major PM “families” : “Waterfall” (traditional, sequential) and “agile”.

One… wait… two more things, though:

When talking about “Agile” I am mainly referring to the mindset and way of thinking rather than one specific method, based on the “Manifesto for agile software development” (Beedle et al., 2001).

The manifesto lists four core values:

Royce (1970) visualised the probably first and later referred to as “waterfall” PM method, incorporating a two-sided relationship between development phases. He linked each phase back to its predecessor acknowledging potential iterations.

“Waterfall” has often been falsely visualised in a “one-way only” manner. Thus, it has been accused of being strictly linear, making it impossible or at least difficult to move back, once a step has been made.

When relating to “waterfall” in my context I refer to the iterative notion introduced by Royce.

Project Management and the Revamped Double Diamond

Although visually implying, the “Revamped Double Diamond” shouldn’t be perceived as one-way process and account for an agile and iterative behaviour.

There are different approaches to tackling design challenges, the related process and PM.

They depend on the type of organisation that is taking upon them, their focus and role within the challenge, restrictions and boundaries given by the project scope and a desired outcome of a project.

Depending on these variables the process and focus on phases may vary (Sam Dunne, 2016).

Merging PM approaches and the Revamped Double Diamond

How might we apply PM approaches to the Design process?

Two visual approaches:

Discover and Define meet Sprint 0, Assumptions and Hypotheses

The core notion of the approach overlaying “Discover and Define” with “Sprint 0, Assumptions and Hypotheses” is thorough research as foundation of a project.

“The goal is to ensure “the right problem to solve” or “the question to ask” is addressed.”

Contrary, quickly building assumptions of user behaviours based on the initial brief may be another approach to starting a project.

Jeff Gothelf (2013) points out that Lean UX projects start with assumptions summarised in a problem statement. Assumptions go into a prioritisation process, in which they are placed on a two-axis matrix.

Certainty vs Proximity Matrix

The point of prioritising assumption is to come up with formulating a hypothesis statement that looks at potential solutions that are the foundation for generating ideas that might be tested later.

“The hypothesis statement sets a clear vision for the work.”

The activity of formulating and prioritising assumptions may be related to the Revamped Double Diamond stage of “Defining and Synthesising” whereas phrasing hypotheses and ideate may be considered as a form of “Design / Ideation”.

Relating to a scrum methodology the first diamond plus the “Design / Ideation” subphase can also be considered “sprint 0”.

Unlike “waterfall projects”, scrum projects are made of so-called sprints, which are portions of a project that usually last for a defined number of weeks in which a multidisciplinary team works together on a challenge (“Get Agile”, Pieter Jongerius and Gert Hans Berghuis, 2013).

Get Agile

Although scrum is a progress driven PM approach that doesn’t leave lots of space for creativity, neither creativity nor UX need to fall short as Jongerius and Berghuis claim.

Sprint 0 should serve a space to plan and make space for all activities that do not necessarily find lots of time in later sprints.

The goal is to set up a clear vision, team support and strategy for the following sprints and the entire project.

Develop and Deliver meet Sprints and Loops

Creating hypotheses mentioned in the previous paragraph relates to the “Design / Ideation” phase of the “Revamped Double Diamond”.

“Gothelf considers collaboration the most effective way to rally a team around a design direction, helping teams to build a shared understanding of the problem and solution.”

Collab—after standing around walls you might want to sit down at some point

Following “Design / Ideation”, the “delivery” phase is about applying a “build-measure-learn” loop. This loop aims at minimising project risk and getting teams building quickly and learning quickly. Teams build Minimum Viable Products (MVPs) and ship them quickly to begin the process of learning as early as possible.

The goal is to test whether assumptions or ideas are viable to achieve an overall desired outcome.

“Assumptions of potential solutions or hypotheses (set of ideas) should be made tangible and testable.”

Eric Ries’s (2011) “build-measure-learn” loop (from “The Lean Start Up”) has been used in various process models. Depending on the model, source, or methodology namings might differ:

While “build-measure-learn” is a constant circular approach, scrum projects often consist of three to four sprints per project in this stage of the project, following sprint 0.

Team is everything

“If they are not A TEAM, who else? – Img Source Link

“Team is everything” is a core principle at Hyper Island. It is believed that collaboration, inclusion and transparency are crucial to growth.

This principle is infused by practising and applying team building, team “maintenance” and team termination tools and activities.

The goal is to build and maintain a strong culture and therefore effective teams by fostering trust and openness for better collaboration.

Culture is a core component of successful teams and companies. As Brian Chesky states, airbnb got its $150m investment by Peter Thile partially thanks to their culture. His core take-away: Don’t F*ck Up the Culture.
Teams are also essential in an agile mindset. The agile manifesto puts “individuals and interactions over processes and tools”, and lists specific principles putting emphasis on team, collaboration and culture:

Gothelf advocates a high level of collaboration between different disciplines, too. He encourages conversation and sharing insights between representatives from each discipline to drive greater team efficiency.

“Design Thinking is about the people you are designing for and the people you are designing with.”

Conclusion

No matter what PM methodology you apply to a Human/User Design or Design Thinking process, “team and people are everything”, as a final outcome of a project is usually tailored to improve the lives of people.

Applying the Revamped Double Diamond as a framework to tackle design challenges and overlaying it with project management methodologies is not contradictory. It may help when trying to implement the framework into “real world” practice.
As the agile mindset suggests, there is no fixed and exclusive way to execute project management or any specific method.

Teams and organisations ought to stay open and adaptive to cope with ever changing “real world” challenges.

This article was originally published on Dan’s Medium page.

Get started with Marvel Enterprise

Get started with Marvel Enterprise

From CEOs to marketing, get your entire organisation collaborating in one place.

Get started with Enterprise

After finishing a Digital Experience Design Master’s programme at Hyper Island, Dan is joining Swiss agency, Hinderling Volkart, as Experience Director UX. He teaches as a part-time lecturer and for almost ten years, has held positions in the digital field at agencies such as Jung von Matt/Limmat, Publicis and Scholz & Friends.

Related Posts

I recently worked on defining the spacing system for Practice Fusion’s EHR (Electronic Health Record) product, to ensure improved readability and consistency across all pages. I came up with 3 spacing rules (hint: rule of 3 C’s) and 4 spacing values, which worked harmoniously well with the new typographic system. The problem “When positioning elements vertically, the designer has to… Read More →

A selection of prototypes, photos, and learnings from Design Club at a special CoderDojo We recently joined CoderDojo London to deliver two days of workshops for 7–17 year-olds. We were hosted by UCL at Base KX, near Kings Cross. There were tables dotted about, offering coding activities. There were computers everywhere. Except on our table. We we were unplugged. Okay,… Read More →

“Dashboard”, “Big Data”, “Data visualization”, “Analytics” — there’s been an explosion of people and companies looking to do interesting things with their data. I’ve been lucky to work on dozens of data-heavy interfaces throughout my career and I wanted to share some thoughts on how to arrive at a distinct and meaningful product. Many people have already tackled this topic,… Read More →